The Madison City Council voted Tuesday to refer an ordinance to ban alcohol sold in amounts smaller than a six-pack to its first June meeting to provide more time for debate from alders and industry leaders.
The proposed ordinance would ban the sale of beer and malt liquor in amounts less than a six-pack of bottles, liquor in the amounts of 200 milliliters or less and the sale of fortified wine for consumption off the premises on which it was sold.
Districts 4 and 8, two downtown districts near and including the University of Wisconsin campus, already have this ban in effect as a result of the Madison Alcohol License Review Committee’s vote on July 1, 2008. Under the current ordinance, the ban would take effect for the whole city Sept. 1.
According to ordinance sponsor Ald. Michael Schumacher, District 18, this is part of a wider effort to curb alcohol abuse in the city. The ban targets public intoxication and habitual drinking among a specific population, including chronic abusers of alcohol.
“We are beginning to see problems with people buying so called ‘cheap liquor,’” Schumacher said. “… Through panhandling, they buy the next bottle of cheap booze, the smallest bottles and the cheapest ones.”
Representatives of retailers and alcohol distributors voiced their opposition to the ban at Tuesday’s meeting. Most of the speakers against the ordinance said the ban did not specifically address the problem of public intoxication and alcohol abuse but rather punishes law-abiding citizens interested in buying the alcohol products.
“This is a broad resolution to a minor problem,” said Bill White of the Wisconsin Grocer’s Association. “Thousands and thousands of people enjoy these products in small containers.”
White added he wants more time for the alcohol industry to be brought into the discussion to come to alternative solutions. One of these solutions would be incorporating retailers not selling to known alcohol abusers on a voluntary basis.
Casey Trudgeon, executive vice president and general manager of Wisconsin Distributors, echoed White’s opposition, saying the ordinance was not attacking the problem of alcohol abuse directly.
“Why are we attacking the product or the package and not the person that has the problem?” Trudgeon said.
After public discussion, Schumacher motioned for the vote to be referred because he wanted to give members of the alcohol industry a chance to come to the discussion table on the topic. The council voted in favor, pushing the vote back to the June 2 City Council meeting.
Ald. Mark Clear, District 19, commended Schumacher on referring the vote to another meeting.
“It’s a great show of leadership on Schumacher’s part, because I believe he thinks he has enough votes to go forward with this but is showing a willingness to work with the community and industry leaders on this,” Clear said.





IP hash: c6b1b7ab
NOT MY 40’S!
IP hash: 6fabc93d
Some of the best and most expensive craft beer comes in 4-packs. WTF?
IP hash: 051726d1
I’m sure bums are buying $7 4 packs of microbrew to get drunk. Find something better to do.
IP hash: d9ad7d4a
All this is doing is forcing the “problem drinkers” to buy larger quantities. Nice work Schumacher.
IP hash: 63585b6b
Horray 6 packs!
IP hash: 907e3c63
I can’t believe Ald. Shumacher is actually trying to suggest that the drinking problem is a primarily a “panhandler” problem. I’m going to go out on a limb here and suggest that a lot of alcohol abuse in the Madison area is done by young students who are are happy to buy a 30 pack.
IP hash: 4c32ddff
what a surprise that this city is once again doing something ass-backwards
IP hash: 59e2b87e
The text of the ban exempts “craft” beer, FYI.
IP hash: 97d91588
�We are beginning to see problems with people buying so called �cheap liquor,�� Schumacher said. �� Through panhandling, they buy the next bottle of cheap booze, the smallest bottles and the cheapest ones.�
Uh, make it illegal to panhandle maybe? Tell them to get a job. Don’t give me that mentally disabled BS. If they ARE mentally disabled, letting them panhandle doesn’t give them the help they need, so why let them keep doing it? They just “panhandle” (or beg for money, lets call it what it is) for a few more hours to buy a 6 or 12 pack. I also find it strange when I walk by them begging for money and they are sometimes dressed nicer than me or listening to headphones. This is just like that stupid barrel law they tried to pass: use faulty logic to try and punish a large group of people for the actions of a few.
IP hash: 0a23ab05
I agree with the previous posts. Craft beers (even from local brewers like New Glarus) will often come in four-packs. In addition, 6-packs of discount beers like Molson still run in the $4-6 range. This ordinance will accomplish nothing. Contact your council person and tell them to stop wasting time with useless measures such as this.
http://www.cityofmadison.com/Council/documents/2009publicroster.pdf
IP hash: fd693628
This just in: poor people will no longer allowed to legally imbibe alcohol.