Opinion

Stealing culture and identity

On Tuesday, May 6, The Daily Cardinal came out with an interesting front-page photo showing two students smoking the Argeelah (Hookah) at an Israeli event. The interesting part of the story is that the Argeelah, often introduced as an Israeli delicacy, has never been a part of the 55-year-old Israeli culture and is a perfect symbol for the violations that have and are occurring in Palestine and on the Palestinian people. This cultural theft is not limited to the pages of the Daily Cardinal or to the Madison media in general, but it is a national and international phenomenon.

Throughout the first half of the 20th century, Jewish immigrants, fearing persecution in Europe, fled to Palestine to seek refuge. In 1948, these immigrants and their illegal underground militias such as Pal Mach, Haganah, and the Irgun took over the Palestinian lands, completely destroyed 418 villages (damaging many others), and created one of the largest and longest-lasting refugee waves in history. Nearly a million Palestinians, according to United Nation accounts, were and are still displaced into neighboring countries.

However, occupying Palestine was not the hardest part of the mission. After taking over the land, Israel had to convince the world that it was a “land with know man” (a Zionist expression used to promote Palestine in the Western world as a Jewish homeland). Israelis then began the process of seizing the culture of the native inhabitants and calling it their own. This has proven to be their toughest mission of all.

Many Palestinian cultural characteristics have been systematically wiped out through the destruction of entire villages, the demolition of traditional buildings, cultural institutions, and historical sites, as well as the steeling and hiding of any pieces of Palestinian archeology found in the area, which could date as far back as 8,000 years — the official estimated age of the cities of Jaffa and Jericho.

Other characteristics are too difficult to hide. The everyday costumes and traditions that are being practiced regularly by the native population are not easy to “knock out.” These aspects of the culture, imbedded in the region, are Israel’s greatest challenge. Recently, however, we have been exposed to new tactics. Israel is now trying to claim the many traditions and traditional items of the Palestinian people, as their own.

The Argeelah, a water pipe used to smoke marinated tobacco, has been in use for hundreds of years on the banks of the Nile, passing by Palestine and Syria, all the way to Turkey, as well as in Iraq and the Arabian Peninsula. It has been a part of the culture of the area long before Israel existed or before Europe’s Jews thought of migrating to Palestine. But lately, it is not uncommon to hear an Israeli calling the Argeelah a “Jewish pipe” or introducing it as an Israeli item, even though most of the ones they use have arabesque decorations on them and sometimes even Arabic writings or verses from the Qur’an.

Hummus, falafel, and Baba Ghanouj are world-famous Palestinian and Syrian dishes; they have been in that region probably since the Canaanites planted the northern and costal planes of Palestine with chick pees — the main ingredient in hummus and falafel. However, if you are to receive a postcard from somebody in Israel, you are likely to receive one that features a Falafel sandwich next and an Israeli flag inviting you to try Israel’s “traditional cuisine.” Similarly, if you happened to have an Israeli friend, he may invite you to a Mediterranean restaurant, very likely owned by a Palestinian, to treat you to some hummus and Baba Ghanouj, calling it “Israeli food.”

Olive trees cover most of the green landscape of Palestine. Olive and olive oil have been a major agricultural crop of Palestine since before the Roman Occupation over 2,000 years ago. But for the last three decades, Israel uprooted thousand and thousands of olive trees and took many of them, mainly the centuries-old looking ones, to be re-planted in cities with predominantly Israeli populations. As a result, Palestinian olive oil is being marketed in the United States and Europe as a “product of Israel.”

The organizers of Israel Day know that they are stealing a cultural identity from the people they have occupied and disposed. They even had the audacity to ask Palestinians in Madison to make the falafel for the festival. If it is their food, why do they need Palestinians to make it? Cultural theft and the occupation of identity are serious crimes. They are no less significant than taking away land, basic human rights or even the right to live, and they are ultimately denying Palestinians the right to enjoy their own culture by claiming it for their own.

Fayyad Sbaihat ([email protected]) is a senior majoring in chemical engineering.

Have a thought? We welcome your input, but please be polite and stay on topic wherever possible. Your comment may be deleted if it is inappropriately off topic or promotional or if it is unnecessarily rude or contains personal attacks. We may delete comments for other reasons as well. Just keep it simple and focus on your points as respectfully as possible.

We allow and encourage comments employing satire, wit and irony to make points. Do not flag comments just because you disagree. Flagged comments will be immunized from further flagging unless they stray far from the guidelines and do not add to the discussion. Before flagging a comment you think is offensive, consider your time might be better spent rebutting it than censoring it.

blog comments powered by Disqus

2 older comments

user-pic

It’s funny…Fayyad talks about the “Roman Occupation.”

Guess who ruled the land before the Romans occupied it? I’ll give you a hint: it wasn’t the Palestinians.

In fact, the name “Palestine” came into being as a way for the Romans to insult the Jews from whom they conquered the land. It was a reference to the Philistines, the Jews’ rivals in Biblical times, who were relegated to a narrow strip of land in what is today the Gaza Strip and the Northern Sinai Peninsula.

As for “cultural theft” and “occupation of identity” being serious crimes, well, that’s true, but it’s simply not happening here. Israel has been the Jewish homeland for over 3000 years, long before “Palestinians” ever existed. The cultural items Fayyad refers to in this article are REGIONAL items and foods that were around long before “Palestinians” ever existed. If anything, the “Palestinians” stole them from the Jews.

And in any case, Fayyad, isn’t a campaign of terror aimed at murdering innocent people — what your buddies in Hamas, Islamic Jihad, Fatah, and the PFLP are doing to Israelis — a much more serious crime?

user-pic

This is certainly been proved by my experiences, to the extent that being called a “Yid” on the street has been more common than being called a “Dirty Arab” and I am glad someone finally picked up on this! European jews have had their own rich cultre, with the succes of bagels and pretzels as testament ot this (not to say these are the only things, but damn if theyre not the tastiest!) and I cannot see why on earth they decide to steal practises from a cultre they deem “inferior”. I know some people will claim that Israel existed first, so any cultural practisies which have sprung up in the next 3000 years somehow belong to the people who emmigrated from the USA and Europe into Palestine. however they miss the point that the “Jews” who lived in “Israel” at that time 3000 years ago are more connected to the Arabs than European Jews, as most converted to Christianity with the onset of Christ and then later on to Islam when the prophet Muhammed arrived. The sizable number of jews who didnt convert remained in Palestine and had the same rights as the Muslims and Christians to the land and many of the cultural practises. So the Palistinian Christians and Muslims currently being persecuted by Israel indeed do have the same if not a stronger case for being in palestine, and didnt suddenly “appear” as some people believe and barbarically seize the land, they were just the product of cultural and religious change. Email me at [email protected] to discuss any of these points

Donate