Opinion

‘Mayhem’ merely fear mongering

Madison Mayor Dave Cieslewicz is ready for battle. He tried to stop it after last year's "melee," forcefully stating, "We had up until this point, we've said we're going to welcome this event. In a way it's going to be part of the fabric of Madison … no more." That plan has failed, as around 75,000 intoxicated, costumed partiers will invade the downtown area in an annual beer blast like no other in the country: Madison's infamous Halloween celebration.

The mayor, certain local officials and a number of media outlets have been beating the drum all year long about the upcoming event for political and sensationalistic reasons; redefining what it means to fear monger in a way that would make Stephen King proud.

Mr. Cieslewicz has threatened to use his mayoral power to invoke martial law in the city, forcing all downtown bars to close at his discretion. The mayor's undiplomatic threat comes after many bar owners are upset over the recent smoking ban's damaging economic effects on their businesses. Dane County Tavern League president and bar owner Barb Mercer told the Wisconsin State Journal that she would not comply with the mayor's request to close the bars early: "This is not going to happen. This is an industry that has been beaten up, sat on, chewed up and spit out. I'm angry."

Of course, the mayor probably didn't take into consideration that if people don't drink at the bars, they usually go to a less safe, unregulated house party to do a few keg stands. It's kind of like how the 2002-2003 downtown drink special ban was supposed to reduce crime, but actually resulted in a 35.6 percent increase in police calls for disorderly conduct.

I still remember watching CNN the day after the 2002 Halloween riots. "Mayhem in Madison" flashed across the bottom of the screen as a handful of looters were shown, not ironically, stealing more alcohol from State Street Liquor. If you just read the sensationalized headlines or listened to the local television reports, you would have thought that every Halloween following had turned Madison's downtown into some sort of Fallujah-like terrorist hotbed for the final weekend in October.

The truth is, out of the tens of thousands of Halloween revelers that embark on downtown each year, the violence, destruction and mayhem has been way overblown. Consider this: in 2003, police reported 350 alcohol-related offenses and in 2004, a total of 458 citations were given, mostly to out of town partygoers. Last year, with an estimated 75,000 alcohol-filled adults, the number of citations issued amounted to a measly 0.6 percent of the total crowd.

Over the past year, there has been talk of every extreme measure from completely closing down the city to restricting access to downtown by quarantining the area through police enforcement. The University of Wisconsin has even succumbed to the fear tactics by instituting a ban on guests in the dorms from Friday, Oct. 28 through Tuesday, Nov. 1. I guess the UW's contribution to making the city "safer" is having out of town guests roam the streets all night long in a drunken stupor even after the rest of the partiers head home.

I refuse to accept the premise of the argument that says Madison turns into "Mayhem" every Halloween. Sure, there are always a handful of drunken idiots who cause problems. Arrest those people, fine them and throw them in jail. For the rest of us, stop the fear mongering! This isn't some sleepy suburb of Salt Lake City where the most trouble ever caused is a verbal disagreement over who was the first to shout "Bingo" at the annual block party.

Evoking martial law on Halloween is as ridiculous as bringing in an armed National Guard for a home football game to control the belligerent drunks. The truth is that Halloween is a part of the fabric of Madison, just like the Mifflin Street Block Party and UW football games. It's a tradition that students look forward to and that (some) remember as a part of their college careers.

The negativity and fear mongering surrounding the event is patently absurd and exaggerated. There will undoubtedly be some violence and fighting caused by a few people who think that their manhood is somehow enhanced by irrational, testosterone-induced physical confrontations. However, most people remain civil, and their biggest problem is going to be the next morning's hangover. They are simply out to have a good time and party with their friends. I'm looking forward to yet another successful Halloween weekend in Madison this year.

Casey Hoff ([email protected]) is a UW student and host of "New Ground with Casey Hoff," live Monday through Friday, 9-11 a.m., on Madison 1670 The Pulse.

Have a thought? We welcome your input, but please be polite and stay on topic wherever possible. Your comment may be deleted if it is inappropriately off topic or promotional or if it is unnecessarily rude or contains personal attacks. We may delete comments for other reasons as well. Just keep it simple and focus on your points as respectfully as possible.

We allow and encourage comments employing satire, wit and irony to make points. Do not flag comments just because you disagree. Flagged comments will be immunized from further flagging unless they stray far from the guidelines and do not add to the discussion. Before flagging a comment you think is offensive, consider your time might be better spent rebutting it than censoring it.

blog comments powered by Disqus

4 older comments

user-pic

Sounds to me like Hoff is living in some sort of fantasy world where people go skipping hand in hand down State Street for Halloween. Unfortunately there has been major abuse downtown for Halloween every year and a lot of people have had it. The percentage of people that are fined/arrested doesn’t matter. How many people got away with something? The damage that does occur is far beyond a little drunken brawl.

You get your digs in about economic hardships for small businesses over the smoking ban but what about all the damage caused to State Street businesses on Halloween? They have to deal with higher insurance premiums and pay higher deductibles to pay for that damage. What about the store that was forced to close it’s doors because their windows got broken and people looted and damaged everything inside? That is part of the “mayhem” that you refuse to believe occurs.

So of course there needs to be discussions on the best ways to deal with Halloween. Where are your solutions, Hoff? All you do is turn your head and pretend that it’s some sort of “boys will be boys” thing. And I applaud our school for disallowing visitors over Halloween weekend. If anyone is too stupid to visit Madison without a place to stay then they deserve whatever trouble that they get into.

On an unrelated note, I wonder if WTDY pays the Badger Herald to promote Hoff’s extremely low-rated radio show/station at the bottom of each week’s column.

user-pic

Mr. Hoff claims the drink special ban resulted in an increase of police calls related to disorderly conduct. Post hoc ergo propter hoc….Where is the proof?

user-pic

There is a serious problem with Halloween in Madison. It used to be fun; now it is out of control. To suggest that there is no problem is incredibly naive.

user-pic

The mayor already has announced that he won’t use his emergency powers. Nice try, Mister Irrelevant.

Donate