The Dalai Lama stops here today on his world tour, teaching for three days before speaking to thousands of students — myself among them — at the Kohl Center Friday. In recognition of his visit, the City-County Liaison Committee will hoist the Tibetan Flag over the Madison City-County Building, just under the United States' own star-studded banner. The Dalai Lama was honored in the same fashion during his last visit in 1998, with little dissent. This time, two organizations — Madison's Freedom from Religion Foundation and the Chinese government — have objected to use of the flag. Perhaps a testament to the Dalai Lama's multi-faceted role, these groups protest the display of the Tibetan flag for what some would consider opposite reasons: One believes the Dalai Lama is too religious a figure; the other holds he is too political. At least two leaders of the Freedom from Religion Foundation dispute the city and county's commemoration. Co-president Annie Laurie Gaylor opined that by flying the flag "basically to honor a religious figure, it becomes a state-church issue," according to the Wisconsin State Journal. Also, co-president Dan Barker reasons that, "Since the Dalai Lama is a religious leader, we cannot use our government buildings or money to endorse him." Millions of Buddhists worldwide call the Dalai Lama both spiritual leader and 14th incarnation of the Bodhisattva of Compassion; no one can deny his religious status. Yet by focusing solely on his religion, the Freedom from Religion Foundation flagrantly ignores the positive impact the Dalai Lama creates in the world outside Buddhism. The Dalai Lama's struggle for peace and civil rights in his native Tibet — currently under the suppressive rule of China since 1949 — coupled with his constant campaign for the practice of compassion and tolerance toward everyone earned him a Nobel Peace Prize in 1989 and will earn him a Congressional Medal of Honor this fall. If Madison wanted to greet the Dalai Lama as a religious leader, it would fly an image of the Buddha — an act even less likely than nailing a crucifix to the flagpole. Instead, the local government will recognize his work by raising the flag of his native Tibet, the country for which he has struggled to restore peace and some semblance of democratic autonomy. The Chinese consulate in Chicago also opposes Madison's display, but for different reasons. Zhiyuan Ji, consul of the political and press office for the Chinese Consulate General, told the Wisconsin State Journal that it is "not appropriate for the city to pass a resolution to welcome [the Dalai Lama] and plan to fly a so-called Tibetan flag." In an e-mail to Mayor Dave Cieslewicz, Mr. Ji asserted that the Dalai Lama is "not merely a religious figure, but a political exile … [whose purpose] is to engage in activities aimed at splitting China and undermining China-U.S. relations under the cover of religion." China has occupied Tibet for 58 years, denying both the legitimacy of the exiled Tibetan government — the Dalai Lama is the head of this government — and the fact that Tibet was ever legally separate from China. I have neither the space nor the relevancy to discuss my views on the China-Tibet situation, though they are probably pretty obvious, anyway. In any event, Dane County has more than enough justification to recognize Tibet and honor its exiled political leader, who has worked so hard to preserve basic human rights and cultural identity for Tibetans. China's occupation of Tibet more than half a century ago was, and still is, far too controversial for the Chinese consulate to be "astonished," as Mr. Ji wrote, at Madison's actions. China should also understand that a Midwestern county does not represent the federal U.S. government, who recognizes China's possession of Tibet. Dane County is allowed to voice opinions that run contrary to the official U.S. stance — South Carolina's display of the confederate flag is an especially relevant example. Ultimately, both the Freedom from Religion Foundation and the Chinese consulate limit the Dalai Lama's message. One group perceives him as a primarily religious figure, while the other assumes he is bent on destroying Chinese interests. The Dalai Lama certainly fills a major religious role, and he does conflict with China's currently inflexible intentions by pushing for some degree of autonomy for Tibet. However, the Dalai Lama promotes much broader issues that apply to everyone, regardless of religion or nationality; compassion, tolerance and basic human rights are just some of them. The Dalai Lama himself best sums it up on his website: "I believe that at every level of society — familial, tribal, national and international — the key to a happier and more successful world is the growth of compassion. We do not need to become religious, nor do we need to believe in an ideology. All that is necessary is for each of us to develop our good human qualities." Jack Garigliano ([email protected]) is a freshman majoring in English.
Opinion
Tibetan flag flap should blow over
By Jack Garigliano
Wednesday, May 2, 2007 12:00 a.m.
Updated Wednesday, May 2, 2007 11:42:20 p.m.
Have a thought? We welcome your input, but please be polite and stay on topic wherever possible. Your comment may be deleted if it is inappropriately off topic or promotional or if it is unnecessarily rude or contains personal attacks. We may delete comments for other reasons as well. Just keep it simple and focus on your points as respectfully as possible.
We allow and encourage comments employing satire, wit and irony to make points. Do not flag comments just because you disagree. Flagged comments will be immunized from further flagging unless they stray far from the guidelines and do not add to the discussion. Before flagging a comment you think is offensive, consider your time might be better spent rebutting it than censoring it.
Top Classified Ads (view all)
Place your classified ad online and have it show up here. Your ad will hit thousands of viewers a day!
Looking for a print version?
Simply use your browser’s ‘Print’ command and a printer-friendly document will be generated automatically.
Related stories:
- Saving Tibet not worth trouble (March 28, 2008)
- Howard: Does a pope's death warrant flag lowering? (April 11, 2005)
- Readers vanquish foes (December 1, 2006)
- Readers type, click post (October 27, 2006)
- It ain't me (January 23, 2003)
Also by Jack Garigliano:
- Liberal arts need funds and focus (November 12, 2008)
- Obama is first step, now get off your ass and work (November 6, 2008)
- GOP stoops too low for Joe Sixpack to stomach (October 30, 2008)
- Pluralism failed by UW's silence (October 16, 2008)
- Holistic admissions hurt the best (October 9, 2008)
10 older comments




IP hash: 74dd0677
It has blown over. Old news.
IP hash: 21354664
The title is cool because flapping and blowing are things that flags do! I’m clever. - Germain Q. Stemme
IP hash: 69d6e8d1
Maybe the state should honor JC and his “struggle for peace” and the “constant campaign for the practice of compassion and tolerance toward everyone” ?
IP hash: 10559ab4
7:17, don’t they already? State offices are closed several days a year in his honor.
IP hash: 6b13f9df
“All that is necessary is for each of us to develop our good human qualities.”
I hope not. I don’t think happiness comes from just developing good human qualities. That seems really existential. The truth must be deeper than that.
IP hash: 04a67e74
They should also fly the Tibetan flag in Washington DC and at the UN. Congrads to the brave people and officials of Madison, one could only wish goverments on a national level would also show their opposition to the heartless and selfish Chinese colonization of Tibet rather than to be blinded by their dreams of how much money they will make from China if they go along with its government’s policies.
IP hash: 8dcdff2a
Happy to see the Tibetan flag free tibet
IP hash: de106045
Do you really know what Dalai’s current policy is?
Here is Dalai’s latest policy regarding China-Tibet relationship:
“Once we get meaningful autonomy … we will be loyal and there will be more unity and genuine stability,” he told the VIPs in attendance, including Democratic Sen. Dick Durbin of Illinois. “We are not seeking (full) independence and separation.”
http://www.phayul.com/news/article.aspx?article=In+Chicago%2C+Dalai+Lama+urges+China+to+change+Tibet+policies&id=16467
That is to say, Dalai thinks Tibet is part of China.
Now do you still think Tibet should be independent?
IP hash: 52fb6d73
is it true that the next reeincarnation of the Dalhi~Lama is in jeopardy because of his exile?
greywolf sendzz…
IP hash: 4fd9ae10
During that time problem came out from china ambessy . But the courage of madison wi gov it sucess,