Opinion

For once: Take after Minnesota

At the University of Minnesota, something big is happening. Well, yes, the football team is 6-1 for the first time since man set foot on the moon, but my sources tell me they are really just shell-shocked and reality has yet to fully sink in. No, what those crazy Gophers are really excited about is… transportation!

For those of you who do not keep close tabs on the Minneapolis campus of “the U,” as it is colloquially referred to by its denizens, big changes are about to take place on their Washington Avenue — the street that essentially divides the campus in two, separating the freshman dorms and some facilities from the rest of campus as well as the entertainment district. This is analogous to our University Avenue. (Oddly enough, their University Avenue runs from the campus to the capitol just like our Washington Avenue — whoa.)

But just wait, it gets freakier. Some of you may know that Madison is planning construction on University Avenue for this coming summer. Now before you start fleeing north, Minnesota is planning on doing the same thing to Washington Avenue. This, however, is where the comparisons end. Minnesota is planning on turning their great divide into a pedestrian mall that is only periodically divided by a train. Madison — well, Madison is just gonna pour some new concrete and see how things turn out.

It is pretty widely accepted that we have one of the best campuses in the Big Ten. Minnesota is comprised of three separate campuses, Champaign-Urbana is pretty much a truck stop, and Northwestern was alcohol-free until 1975. Nevertheless, our university and our city should not be resting on its laurels. Though we have soaring research towers, beautiful brick buildings, rolling hills and giant lakes, we should be continually trying to improve our campus.

For the most part, we are doing that. Campus plan 2030 will address buildings like Humanities, Noland Hall and Van Hise. The Murray St. Mall will unite the north and south ends of the east side, and a new Union South will anchor the midwestern part of campus and engineering regions. One thing that is not addressed, however, is University. One of the few negative things that struck me as a prospective student back in 2006 was that the campus was divided in two by this pseudo-freeway. Reducing the level of traffic on this street would improve our central campus more than any freshly cured concrete surface could.

Now I hate to say it, but maybe we should follow Minnesota’s lead on this one. A pedestrian mall similar to State Street would be pretty sweet, and if the sushi cart is that much closer to my classes, so much the better. It would also be easy to run any future light rail line (as in Madison’s plan for 2020) through this corridor. Even diverting enough traffic to close one or two lanes and put in a nice green boulevard would bring marked improvement. But since that is a lot of cars to reroute, taking a page out of Boston’s book and going big dig style to build a giant tunnel would probably be the ideal solution.

Now I don’t have all, or any, of the kinks worked out, but at some point University will have to be addressed. As the population of Madison continues to grow, traffic will have to be rerouted or the street expanded. I am suggesting we begin looking into it now. Even in these dire financial times, I’m sure the city and the university can kick together a couple thousand dollars to fund some grad students to do a feasibility study on the situation. After all, they somehow found $300,000 to spend on a feasibility study for a trolley system. It found, as any preschooler could have told you, that while a trolley system has good qualities from a theoretical standpoint, the actual transition from the brio set to the street would be quite complicated.

So here we sit with a pretty nice campus divided by an eyesore of a busy street. And despite all the construction scheduled to take place, it doesn’t look like it’s going to change anytime soon. But that’s not even the worst part. The Gophers are 6-1.

Joey Labuz ([email protected]) is a junior majoring in biomedical engineering.

Have a thought? We welcome your input, but please be polite and stay on topic wherever possible. Your comment may be deleted if it is inappropriately off topic or promotional or if it is unnecessarily rude or contains personal attacks. We may delete comments for other reasons as well. Just keep it simple and focus on your points as respectfully as possible.

We allow and encourage comments employing satire, wit and irony to make points. Do not flag comments just because you disagree. Flagged comments will be immunized from further flagging unless they stray far from the guidelines and do not add to the discussion. Before flagging a comment you think is offensive, consider your time might be better spent rebutting it than censoring it.

blog comments powered by Disqus

10 older comments

user-pic

For an engineer, you have absolutely no clue how much an underground freeway would cost. Where would the money come from? And where would the traffic go during years of construction? Regent or University??

user-pic

“Oddly enough, their University Avenue runs from the campus to the capitol just like our Washington Avenue � whoa.” —- Check out a map sometime University Ave only ever gets within a few blocks of the Capitol. As for the rest of your drivel…I don’t have enough time to exploit all the holes in your “article.” Seriously BH, can’t you find any worthy editorials for these spots?!?

user-pic

Wait. You actually just proposed making Washington Avenue… the city’s biggest non-highway east-west artery… a no car zone?

Good luck gettin that one past the city council.

user-pic

Big Dig style…you obviously aren’t from Boston. And University Ave never harmed anyone…its a road get over it. Campus spreads a lot farther down University ave than it does across…and why would we every follow in Minnesota’s footsteps?

We have State Street, we don’t need two of them!

user-pic

there will not be a train in Madison, even local, for one key reason: Dane County Airport. The Airport fears the if we ever get anything other then light rail the next logical step would be to connect to Milwaukee and Chicago. This would hurt the Airport, as well Badger Bus and Van Galder. The Airport holds enough sway to discourage the trains from ever being built. The fact of the matter is light rail that could grant students access to east town and west town malls and movie theaters would help the local economy by making it easier for students to work and play at those locations. A train to Chicago would help as well, I know people who live in Chicago who would be more then willing to hop a train to come to Madison for a day. Its a big lobby to beat to get a train, realize it’s not as simple as you make. We need get the airport crowd to realize that a train will not kill them and the bus companies to realize they suck.

user-pic

“Oddly enough, their University Avenue runs from the campus to the capitol just like our Washington Avenue � whoa.”

I thought that was State Street.

user-pic

An underground tunnel where University currently is? Are you crazy? First, that would be so unbelievable expensive that a city like Madison wont even come close to footing the bill. Also, keep in mind that University runs right through an Isthmus and University is basically the only way for large amounts of traffic to go from the east side to the west side. If we shut it down to build this rediculous underground tunnel, where do we re-rout the traffic during construction? Do we temporarily split Johnson into a two-way street? No, theres too much traffic dependeing on those streets that an inevitable bottleneck would occur.

So its a nice idea to get cars off of University but its just too impractical to be pulled off.

user-pic

Anonymous (October 22, 2008 @ 6:49am): He’s a BIOMEDICAL Engineer…not a CIVIL Engineer; there is a BIG difference between the two types of engineers. Joey: stick to writing about things you [hopefully] know a little more about (and will actually take the time to fact-check).

user-pic

Yeah a tunnel, now there’s a great idea. Anyone remember the heavy rainfall lately and all the flooding it caused? Where does water naturally seek to go…to the lowest level possible, and your grand tunnel would end up being below lake level, so all the water would naturally drain there. Once you figure out that drainage nightmare, where do you plan on putting all the utilities that cris-cross University Ave & Johnson Street? Did you not see how massive those utility trunk lines are when they were replacing them around the new U-Square? The cost alone on such an endeavour would make the Big Dig seem like a child’s piggy-bank compared to what such an asinine project would cost. If the Bio-med Engineering thing doesn’t work out for you, based on this article, you have a bright future in writing funny short-stories.

user-pic

Okay, I can see making State St. a pedesrian mall, as it should be. It would be relatively painless, and much more practical than your proposal. Baby steps my friend, baby steps.

Donate