Where the ego of Capitol Neighborhoods Inc. is concerned, it seems what you say matters much less than how you say it. In Thursday’s paper, University of Wisconsin professor Richard L. Brown lambasted the Editorial Board for its “snide commentary” on CNI’s inability to attract any participation beyond Associated Students of Madison’s newly appointed student “liaison” to a meeting in which, ironically enough, outreach to students was one of the central issues. As residents of CNI’s jurisdiction, students are entitled to much more representation than an ASM “liaison” — we deserve an equal place at the table.
Brown argued that “from a journalistic perspective,” the Herald often seems more concerned with “isolated remarks” than “giving the issues the attention they deserve.” Sadly, from a journalistic perspective, Brown clearly has no clue whatsoever as to what the purpose of editorial boards actually are. The Editorial Board has absolutely no obligation to engage in objective journalism but rather to comment on the news as it stands.
And as far as Brown is concerned, the news is laughable. As he correctly pointed out, it isn’t our fault we were born into a culture that “makes it normal to go out and get really wasted.”
On the same token, it isn’t Brown’s fault he was born into a culture that makes it normal for paternalistic authoritarians to impose their condescending and entirely arbitrary vision of appropriate behavior on individuals who are adults in a legal and practical sense. Additionally, if Brown sincerely believes CNI is doing all it possibly can, he should have responded to the underlying premise of the editorial, which is that CNI cannot claim to be interested in sincere outreach when it cannot attract students to meetings that are partially about outreach, of all things.
Perhaps, like the Editorial Board opinion in Wednesday’s paper, this column is too “snide” and fails to live up to Brown’s whimsical standards of what journalism is. Fortunately, this is the editorial page. This is where opinions are printed. Opinions are biased. If Brown would like unbiased coverage on the weather or, perhaps, the complete and total inadequacy of his organization’s outreach efforts, he should turn to the news section.
Correction: Due to an editing error, the first sentence of this article referred to Capitol Neighborhoods Inc. as Campus Neighborhoods Inc. We regret the error.





IP hash: 4194d9ee
It’s Capitol Neighborhoods Inc, not Campus Neighborhoods Inc. And there are four students that were elected to the Executive Council, but they have not attended meetings in months. I wish they would— I too believe students should have a voting voice. They do, but choose not to exercise it.
As a member of the Executive Council who is not on the Alcohol Issues Committee (one of over a dozen of our committees), I’ve met Rich Brown once, as he too does not attend our monthly meetings.
I recognize that yours is an opinion column, but I do wish it were a bit more balanced in its view. It seems others have started to take note of CNI’s wide areas of interest; downtown residents are not all crabby old folks getting down on the kids for partying. Many of us are recent graduates or other young professionals, enjoy the nightlife ourselves, and have other issues that are near and dear to our hearts that we work on through CNI. (E.g. transportation, downtown comprehensive plan, homelessness, etc.)
You’re not the only one who has a problem with the tact and people skills of the Alcohol Issues Committee. CNI’s agenda is not as black-and-white as you portray. Somewhere in there, you might find a story.
IP hash: 0391e1e7
It’s a student paper, deal with it.
IP hash: 626fc881
Did you guys pick Brown’s article just so you could yell at him the day after for being authoratarian and paternalistic?
Also, did you read past the first paragraph of Brown’s editorial? I’m a student, and I think opinions from you all in response to Brown’s questions could result in some stimulating conversations among readers.
I know it sucks to be criticized, but come on! Use your positions to help provoke some thought and conversation beyond the level of “All those adults are trying to SCREW us students!!”
IP hash: 653d039a
Even though you piggybacked off my comment on his letter to the editor earlier this week, I’m glad you published this.