Opinion: Guest column

Grad school no promised land in tough times

With graduation a mere fortnight away for the class of 2009, many students feel like they are out of options on the job front and are hoping graduate school will be their saving grace. Although this option provides a seemingly acceptable solution, students need to be sure they are choosing graduate school for the right reasons and not trying to hide from the recession or the real world.

The entire purpose of a student attending graduate school is to increase how marketable they are to potential employers. Deciding on a major as an undergraduate is not as painstakingly important as many students believe, since many jobs require applicants to simply have a bachelor’s degree. For these jobs, employers are not as concerned with specific majors; they merely need to know that a student has the intelligence and competence to graduate. So for undergraduates, it is only logical to major in a field that interests you. However, students who continue onward into graduate school and get a Master’s degree or a Ph.D. in a field that does not offer significant job opportunities or substantial long-term pay actually set themselves up for failure.

Spending exorbitant amounts of money for a degree that does not increase one’s net worth and may not pay for itself is shortsighted, unrealistic and absurd. Usually the on-the-job experience a bachelor’s degree student would receive in the real world during the few years after graduation is much more valuable to employers than a superfluous degree. Not only that, but a Master’s or a Ph.D. candidate will usually demand a higher salary when applying for jobs. If an employer can hire applicants with a bachelor’s degree who can do the job just as well without requiring higher pay, there is no reason not to hire them instead. Since having no career experience puts recent graduates behind the curve already, it does not make sense to add to the deficit with a few more years of grad school before facing the reality of a cutthroat job market.

Students attempting to avoid the job market by staying in academia indefinitely may also face a rude awakening. Even though some students intend to eventually become professors, few students fully understand the reality of the situation. According to The Chronicle of Higher Education, the amount of students who flood into grad schools to become professors may be undermining their own future job prospects. With so many graduate students willing to work like serfs, why would a university ever need to hire more full time personnel? Graduate schools continue to reinforce an idyllic perspective that education opens doors; the more education students receive, the more opportunities they will have in the future. But just because a person has a Ph.D. doesn’t mean they are impervious to unemployment.

There are legitimate reasons to attend graduate school. If students are looking to build upon an existing skill set or focus their training within a specific field, graduate school would be an excellent opportunity to do so. Although some students go to graduate school with a specific career path in mind, other students choose to continue on into graduate school because it is the subsequent step after college. It’s no secret that the real world can be a cruel and unyielding place for recent college grads. While adulthood is rife with uncertainty, climbing the ladder of higher education is comforting and safe; one always knows where to find the next rung. The Associated Press recently reported current graduates will change careers an average of three times in the first five years following graduation. This means graduate students may be paying to go through all of grad school only to change careers within a few years of graduating. Although such unbridled ambiguity about choosing a career can seem daunting, college graduates have much fewer existing responsibilities than older generations and should optimistically view the possibilities available to them. The situation may seem dire for graduates, but students need to make sure if they are considering graduate school, it is really the best option for them. Students should be sure to evaluate the opportunity costs of pursuing an additional degree and applying directly for jobs and weigh them against one another, because pursuing graduate studies just because it feels safe and familiar may prove a detrimentally na�ve decision.

Casey Skeens ([email protected]) is a senior majoring in English and French.

Have a thought? We welcome your input, but please be polite and stay on topic wherever possible. Your comment may be deleted if it is inappropriately off topic or promotional or if it is unnecessarily rude or contains personal attacks. We may delete comments for other reasons as well. Just keep it simple and focus on your points as respectfully as possible.

We allow and encourage comments employing satire, wit and irony to make points. Do not flag comments just because you disagree. Flagged comments will be immunized from further flagging unless they stray far from the guidelines and do not add to the discussion. Before flagging a comment you think is offensive, consider your time might be better spent rebutting it than censoring it.

blog comments powered by Disqus

5 older comments

user-pic

Good observation, Casey. While in school, you should picture yourself working some day. In order to work, you need a trade, which could be as a plumber, electrician, accountant, doctor, lawyer, editor, nurse, etc. Develop your skills and DO something.

user-pic

Casey,

Is there any evidence that students who complete graduate degrees switch jobs less than the average person? Citing the AP article is completely wrong here and your premise is specious at best.

If this is your level of critical thinking and logic, don’t go to graduate school if you want to improve your career prospects. Instead, take a class in mathematical logic or statistics.

user-pic

No matter what option you take, the simple premise this. Just because you have degree, does not mean you will get the easy money right away. Because the main thing people want to see, experience. The diploma you will have is a only a piece of paper saying you studied the subject, but it doesn’t say how’ve you applied it. So the only way to become wealthy with a good degree, is by digging your feet in the mud and begin to climb to the top with a low end job.

user-pic

LOL at 7:13, and another point - are you saying this from your experience so far in the job market, or just what you expect to see? Also being a TA during grad school can make some grad schools more affordable than undergraduate institutions, so why not stay if the job market is bad? Its better than having no money and no job.

“With so many graduate students willing to work like serfs, why would a university ever need to hire more full time personnel?”

Seriously? Have you ever had a class taught by a grad student? Maybe your experience has been better, but mine have been bad so far. You can always tell which ones will go on to be professors and which ones won’t cut it. The university picks to make sure it has the best it can afford (in most cases)

user-pic

hey, at least its not as saturated as law school

Donate