Opinion: Column

Not all involvement sincere, not all apathy worthless

Students at the University of Wisconsin-Madison fall into three demographics: those who genuinely care, those who pretend to care and those who are completely indifferent. As life on campus starts back up and recruitment efforts for student organizations and volunteer work are in full swing, it is important to find out in which category you fall. Are you someone who not only detests suffering but is doing something about it? Are you someone who regurgitates others’ opinions, blindly supports causes and fights against only the trendiest injustices? Or are you apathetic to the world?

First, allow me to speak about those who pretend to care: Any college is destined to be filled with these falsely inspired Wiki-informed world changers. UW is no exception. These are people who wear “Livestrong” bracelets but are overweight and smoke. Who claim to be Rastafarian but really just like weed and dreadlocks, and who think “No Woman, No Cry” is an awesome song. Who have tattoos of Che Guevara on their chests, but don’t know what country he was from. Who spend two hours reading about an issue on Wikipedia and become moved enough to join a Facebook group. Who had two hours to waste on a Tuesday afternoon after reading The New York Times or watching Fox to memorize their favorite columnist’s plan for a better world only to repeat it later as if it were their own. These are people who try desperately to appear opinionated and worldly but, most of the time, have no idea what they’re talking about. And it drives me nuts.

Afraid of appearing ignorant, most less-informed people will avoid challenging the merits of these individuals. This only perpetuates the problem: Those who seize the hottest issue and speak out about it before they have a full understanding of the facts are never deterred from doing so; those who avoid calling them out feel compelled to quickly read up and formulate half-baked opinions of their own.

I will just declare now that I, David Carter, am ignorant. I represent the demographic of those apathetic to the world. I try to live morally, but over an average day, most issues just don’t affect me. When it comes to “saving the whales” or “freeing Tibet” I, frankly, don’t care. And why should I? I don’t know a Japanese whale hunter nor do I know a Tibetan monk. The common person just doesn’t have the time to care about problems occurring outside of their own world. But my “checking out” is more than laziness or apathy. It’s a statement, a choice, a lifestyle. It’s goddamn American.

But then there really are those that are genuinely concerned about an issue. You understand the facts. You are truly sickened by others’ hardships. You work at trying to make things right the best that you know how. I may not join you, but I’ll applaud you. It is you for which I also have sympathy. You have the difficult job of trying to motivate people like me. You also deal with people who prematurely speak out or haphazardly join groups or clubs before being sufficiently informed, cheapening the true spirit of your noble causes.

For those of you truly interested in becoming involved on campus, this is the time of year to do it. The year is just starting, which means that student organizations are just now regrouping. It’s important to get involved. It’s even more important, however, to get involved for the right reasons. Do it because you care. If you care, then by all means join a group or volunteer your time. There is an abundant assortment of righteous political groups on campus. There’s also the Morgridge Center for Volunteering, located in the Red Gym. The staff there is more than helpful. They can serve as your gateway to volunteer opportunities all over Madison, from hospice care to habitat restoration.

But for those for whom awareness of present-day issues is simply a way to create a fa�ade of intelligence and worldliness, I propose you watch from the sidelines until you really understand what the hell you’re talking about. You’re ruining the experience for those that take these matters seriously.

For those of you, like me, that struggle just to find enough purpose to get out of bed in the morning, don’t lose hope. Remember, we are the lifeblood that energizes inactivity. We are responsible for maintaining the status quo. We slow progress to a crawl. We proudly do this without meetings or marches. In fact, we make this big impact with profoundly little effort. We do it by simply choosing to change the channel from CNN to Tyra as we crack another beer.

Ours is a cause many are getting behind. In one of the biggest voter turnouts in history last fall, roughly 59 million of us stayed home. So, I know this high-octane, in your face, and at times pretentious political atmosphere here at UW can make you feel like you’re the only one out there who doesn’t care. Well, I’m here to tell you that I’m with you, along with about 58,999,999 others. And there is something important that the more-involved crowd can learn from us: Nothing is simply a case of right and wrong. There is always the option of indifference. Sometimes saying, “I don’t know” shows greater intelligence and respect for an issue than concocting some drivel-filled opinion about it.

We the ignorant are a large demographic. I’d like to think we’re waiting for the right issue, like a single person waits for the right man or woman to fall in our lap. But regrettably, I’m slowly learning that it doesn’t happen this way. In my journey through indifference, I have come to find that issues, even those that affect and elicit an opinion from me, can’t be changed from the couch (choosing an American Idol finalist notwithstanding). It sucks, I know. But consider that if all 59 million members of the Indifference Party collaborated, maybe our votes for the next election could be texted in. Anything is possible.

Again, I tell you all of this because this is the time of year that campus organization recruiters become most active. Some are genuine, others are not. Some, although they seem like they care, are in it for the wrong reasons. And they’ll be out there, lurking in the bushes with sign-up sheets, searching for others to join their fight. Be prepared. Be knowledgeable. Don’t be lured by promises of free pizza. Don’t be fooled by just any presentation, no matter how elaborate. Make sure you join something you have a vested interest in. The opportunities to join a club and volunteer are out there. The opportunity may even be shoving a flier in your face as you read this.

So whether you genuinely care, are pretending to or are just an ignorant son of a bitch like me, we should all be proactive in learning about what it is we truly care about and finding the right way to express it. Until I find out what that is, you’ll be able to find me at home, accidentally spilling Fruity Pebbles down my bare chest as I watch Maury, wasting another day.

David Carter ([email protected]) is a senior majoring in forestry.

Have a thought? We welcome your input, but please be polite and stay on topic wherever possible. Your comment may be deleted if it is inappropriately off topic or promotional or if it is unnecessarily rude or contains personal attacks. We may delete comments for other reasons as well. Just keep it simple and focus on your points as respectfully as possible.

We allow and encourage comments employing satire, wit and irony to make points. Do not flag comments just because you disagree. Flagged comments will be immunized from further flagging unless they stray far from the guidelines and do not add to the discussion. Before flagging a comment you think is offensive, consider your time might be better spent rebutting it than censoring it.

blog comments powered by Disqus

14 older comments

user-pic

Excellent column, Dave. God only knows we don’t have enough apathy around this town. We could have better parties, though.

user-pic

Sweet life, dude. Yes, you are right we should only care about people we have met. You, my friend, make such an enlightened point. I wonder if your totally super edgy opinion would be the same if you changed places with the majority of the worlds residents who weren’t lucky enough to be born into the most comfortable of circumstances? Embrace your mediocrity and enjoy your meaningless life.

user-pic

You sound like a true douche.

user-pic

Wow. True elitism at its best. Rich white American boy has the luxury to not care about anything…and people who do without joining into some student org. are somehow morally worse than he is.

You need to learn something about the world before assuming that the only interests people care about are ones in Asia (for some reason the only two you mentioned). MOST people in this country are affected deeply by issues you seem to never have heard of (poverty, education/housing discrepancies, discrimination, access to affordable health care…). Yes, I know growing up in a suburban wealthy bubble makes you think most people are just like you…but no, these issues matter to most people, you are the rare and extremely fortunate exception. Your apathetic lifestyle is a luxury that you seem not to be able to contextually appreciate.

And why put down people who may take 18 credits and work two jobs to pay for college who only have time to maybe watch CNN or read a Wikipedia article to get informed? Not everyone has the opportunity to join a student org and must rely on the internet to keep them informed. This article seemed like a diatribe you would drunkenly give to your closed off group of wealthy friends rather than a piece distributed to a group of 17,000 diverse readers.

user-pic

2:27 AM, get a life! Most of the people in this world whose lives suck asked for what they got. And most of them will hate westerners who have it better regardless of what we do to help them. For now, I’ve got me to worry about and that’s all I should have to worry about, so f* off!

user-pic

You bring shame to the University of Wisconsin, a center of activism and political thought. You can’t sift and winnow from your couch, asshole. People like you make me so angry. You are the reason the rest of the world thinks of Americans as stupid, entitled, and self-centered. Go ahead and waste your life away, I hope you’re proud of what you accomplish. Shame on you for this article.

user-pic

This article deserves a little more credit than you give it. Although the beer drinking and TV watching may have been a little over the top, he was honest. He isn’t going to get behind a cause he feels nothing for and that’s a good thing. Why have apathetic people fighting for a cause they don’t believe in? He’s choosing to stay uninvolved until he can become more educated on the issues and I think we can all appreciate that. We should keep an open mind about why it is and how people get involved.

user-pic

I’m not sure if it’s tacky or not to comment on your own article but I just want to clear one thing up: I’m making fun of ignorant people. I didn’t mean to make it sound “edgy”, because that too is lame. More than anything it was supposed to be funny. I also wanted to avoid getting to far up my own ass being preachy about some boring topic. I’m not really as ignorant as I tried to make myself out to be. Should have been clearer; my fault. Thanks for reading it though.

user-pic

4:11 a.m.: Apparently, you’ve forgotten that coming to college has nothing to do with being an activist. In fact, it should be quite the opposite: you should be coming here with an open, submissive mind, ready to learn that perhaps your causes are wrong or misguided (though not necessarily so).

And having been to a few other countries, I can tell you that we are no more “self-centered” than the average global citizen.

That said, the douche-o-meter is giving a rather high reading for this article. I think a balance needs to be struck between 4:11 and the article: you do need to care about a great many things, but at this point in your life, 99% of them should be academic, familiar, or purely local in nature. Why don’t many adults protest for a free Tibet—for that matter, why don’t many adults protest at all? Generally because they find that there are things that matter infinitely more: their families and other unbought graces of life.

user-pic

i liked the article, and love fruity pebbles too. in all seriousness though you are right, there are people on this campus who take themselves and their issues way too seriously, and those who really dont know what they are talking about.

user-pic

Maybe the reason for all the heated criticism of this article stems from the fact that liberals are on their way out the door. Conservatives are already persona non grata among most American voters. Hopefully, enough Americans will begin to see the folly of extremist thought in the minds of both liberals and conservatives and adopt a more moderate, “live and let live” approach. They’ll finally stand up and tell the Democrats and Republicans to take a friggin’ hike.

user-pic

The best lack all conviction, while the worst Are full of passionate intensity.

user-pic

Dave, I really enjoyed this article and appreciate your honesty and sarcasm. You take a different look at why it is poeple get involved. Instead of trying to force someone to join a cause or fight for something you believe in, you tell them to wait until they can truely get behind a cause they feel compelled to fight for! You are more involved and aware than you give yourself credit for. When you finally find an issue that you care deeply about, I think you’ll be able to put down your beer, turn off Tyra (although,that might be hard) and go fight the good fight;) GOOD LUCK DAVE!

user-pic

Dear Mr. Carter,

We’d like to bring you on as spokesperson for our company, Fruity Pebbles. We feel you personify all the values that our company strives for in it’s day to day operations and we believe your point-on reporting of American ideals strikes the very core of our valued customers. We’re in a position to offer you, say, three 16oz boxes of Fruity Pebbles per week. Please consider our offer. We believe this is one cause a guy like you could really get behind, unlike all that other crap in the news.

Ted Nugent CEO Fruity Pebbles

Donate