It was fourth grade when I, along with all my other uniform-clad Catholic school classmates, was gently forced into making my first confession. We didn’t have one of those confessional booths so prevalent in movies and priest abuse legal documents, but the school made up for it by throwing a few chairs in the back chapel. Sitting face-to-face with a man of the cloth, I confessed nine years worth of sins: I fight with my sister sometimes. I don’t always listen to my mom. I wish I had a Sega Genesis like the next-door neighbor. Done. Ten minutes and five Hail Mary’s later, I was relishing in the glory of absolution.
I don’t think I’ve been back since middle school, mostly because confession is terrifying. Talking to strangers is nerve-racking enough; telling all your horrible secrets to an old man in robes feels more like an arraignment hearing than religion. Plus, I’m pretty sure I just stopped sinning, so it didn’t make a ton of sense to waste the precious time of both myself and the Lord. But if one Paris telecommunications company has their way, it may be time to reconsider the policy. After all, I’d still kill for a Genesis, and I think that’s a double-sin.
ABBAS Interactive, the French group responsible for both my newfound optimism and several “Did you mean: ABBA?” Google messages, recently established a confession phone-line, allowing French believers the opportunity to save their souls without the hassle of struggling to find a Catholic church in France. Suddenly, confession doesn’t feel so frightening.
Of course, it isn’t the act itself of confessing that makes people uneasy; it’s the guilt that comes with it. But in-person guilt is exponentially worse than over-the-phone guilt, and if things really get bad, I could always use a fake name.
But no matter what Smashmouth says, not everything that glitters is gold — unless you’re in the Vatican, in which case everything, even the stuff that doesn’t glitter, is. Unfortunately, the service isn’t actually sanctioned by the Conference of French Bishops, which means God can’t give you the “no biggie” shrug and send you on your way with a blank slate. Without the approval of the church — not to mention the use of actual priests — you’re pretty much just talking about dirty stuff into a phone, and if that’s your thing, there are plenty of late-night commercials offering similar services.
But why is the French Church so quick to condemn the idea of telephone confessions? The number of church-goers in Europe has been declining for years, and if people can find a way to work God into their busy, hedonistic lifestyles, maybe there’s still time to prove Nietzsche wrong. The Church could even lift an idea from the laity and start charging for the service; ABBAS went with the .34 Euros-per-minute plan, but I bet the Church could go a little higher. It’s not like God has rollover. And with the new cash stream, the Church could finally afford to buy some more priceless art or pay for that hit on Dan Brown.
Over-the-phone confessions are a great idea because they combat the greatest problem with the modern Church: it’s hard. Sunday morning is a really inconvenient time for a power lecture, and when did God decide that fish doesn’t count as meat? I know the Church has a grudge against reform, but Vatican II was almost 50 years ago. Phone confessions, along with TV mass and in-home transubstantiation (you can probably use Tostitos), would really help bring God into the 21st century, where nobody really cares about Him. But we could change that.
Especially if they’d start taking texts.
Sean Kittridge ([email protected]) is a senior majoring in journalism and history.





IP hash: 2b4d99fd
When I first read the title of this column I thought it might have some good discussions. No, just another ridiculous Herald article posing as something substantial. I don’t claim to be a devout Catholic, but the act of confession being difficult and uncomfortable is part of the point. You sinned and are now actively seeking to make amends; trying to cheat your way out of that is like lying to God. Phone- or text-confessions are just another way for lazy and scared people to feel good about themselves and tell their neighbors that they’re good Catholics. Why not just have your mom write you a Post-It note in your lunch box that says “You’re Saved!”?
Being Catholic is not an easy thing to do, and it shouldn’t be made easier “50 years after Vatican II” just because we as a society don’t have the same religious work ethic anymore. You’re article is severely disturbing and misguided. I’ll pray for you during my “Sunday power lecture”.
IP hash: f473df21
On the contrary, this article pretty much hits the nail on the head. I’m impressed with the author’s insight.
IP hash: 7d38cfed
…I think 3:42am might be missing something here.
IP hash: e0f1e619
“I�ll pray for you…”
Yes, please do. EVERYONE, please pray for Sean, as his articles need all the help they can get. While you’re at it, say an additional one for the BH, too.
IP hash: da8a37df
i guess no practicing catholics read the herald…
IP hash: 3d6b9578
it’s neat how this article was written by a priest.
IP hash: 7c58975f
I have an idea: Father Tim’s CyberConfessional 1.0!
First page-“Welcome, repentant sinner. Click HERE to continue…”
Second page-“Use the checklist of sins and enter the number of times each selected in the accompanying text box. When you are finished, click NEXT at the bottom of this page.”
Third page-“Please wait while Father Tim calculates your penance…”
Final page-“Your penance is [penance here]. Begin typing your penance in the text box below. (NOTE: Your browser’s Copy/Paste function will be disabled.)”
IP hash: e83567af
When I first read the title of this column I thought it might have some good discussions. I thought it might be about how the Catholic church should stop opposing abortion. No, just another ridiculous Herald article posing as something substantial. Though, if they made it into a text message service, you could send in your acts as your doing them!
IP hash: b93ae30d
Why does it matter where you confess? I thought that the god that catholics confess to is omnipotent. I like the phone idea and the text idea even better; make it convenient for folks to ask for forgiveness and make themselves feel better.
IP hash: 9e712b95
You see Sean, there was this guy, let’s call him “Jesus”, he was a pretty awesome man. Did lots of neat stuff. Anyhow, his coup de grace or whatever you want to call it was getting nailed to a tree to save the sins of the whole world. Suffering unimaginable pain so that people could one day be saved. Pretty major sacrifice huh? But you’re right, asking people to come into church instead of texting it in is wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy too much of a sacrifice to ask in return.
IP hash: c11acef4
maybe video chat confessions…but i think the phone is an easy way out. aren’t you supposed to cover local stuff? must have had a lot of exams to resort to the catholic church. you know no one cares about it out here..right?
IP hash: 7a4267f1
In-home transubstantiation… I seriously lol’ed at that one. This article is as silly as the Catholic Church.