Sports: Point-counterpoint

PCP: Phillies or Yankees?

Bruan

If predicting sports games were my job, you could add me to the 9.5 percent of those unemployed in the U.S.

But with the World Series just around the corner, why not give it another shot? Third time’s the charm, right?

At this point, I should be picking the Yankees. With A-Rod playing the way he is and a top-notch three-man rotation, the Bronx Bombers might actually be able to pull this thing off. They made it look relatively easy —though the teams they played didn’t give them much of a challenge — and are finally back in the October Classic for the first time since 2003.

Well, you can say all the great things about the Yankees, but this year, just like every other since 2000, New York will not win a championship because, well, it’s not really the Yankees we’re talking about.

After spending hundreds of millions this past offseason, transactions that some people questioned obviously paid dividends, with CC Sabathia, A.J. Burnett and Mark Teixeira all doing their parts in propelling the Yankees to the World Series.

But this isn’t anything new. Since their last championship in 2000, a team that consisted of home-grown talent like Dave Justice, Bernie Williams and Derek Jeter, the Yankees (or the Steinbrenners) have shifted their ways to instead buy their talent instead of find it.

The Phillies are seemingly the opposite. They aren’t under the wrath of an overpowering owner, and their players are, well, theirs. The Phils’ lineup, strong defense and drive to win will push them to a back-to-back title, incidentally, the first time since the Yankees did it nine years ago.

Bleach

It pains me to write this.

I have spent my entire fanhood rooting against the Yankees almost as hard as I cheer on the Brewers.

The pinstripes represent everything upsetting about baseball to a small market fan. They have ruined any semblance of competitive balance by buying up other teams’ free agents and by the amount of coverage they receive, I’m pretty sure George Steinbrenner secretly owns ESPN.

But the “just spend baby” approach will finally pay off for New York’s 27th World Series title as the Yankees have literally priced out the competition.

I was convinced the baseball playoffs were a crapshoot, but with a $200 million payroll finally allocated properly, the Yankees have bought every number on the board.

The combination of CC Sabathia, A.J. Burnett and Andy Pettitte will overpower the Phillies hitters, especially lefties Chase Utley and Ryan Howard.

The deep Yankees lineup with Derek Jeter, Alex Rodriguez and Mark Teixeira will wear down all of the Phillies arms except for Cliff Lee — the second coming of Pettitte, sans HGH use.

And if you aren’t convinced yet, just compare Mariano Rivera to Brad Lidge. Stacking those two side by side puts things in perspective doesn’t it?

The Phillies have done a nice job reaching the World Series for the second year in a row. The Yankees have more money than several small countries. As usual, the wealthy corporation will crush the local businessman.

6 Comments | Leave a comment

user-pic

First of all…Dave Justice was no where near a homegrown Yankee. Secondly, the Yankees have - Jeter, Pettitte, Mariano Rivera, Posada, Brett Gardner, Robinson Cano, Melky Cabrera, Phil Hughes, Aceves, Joba, Dave Robertson, Phil Coke, and (possibly)Francisco Cervelli - ALL HOMEGROWN - onthe 25 man roster. 13 homegrowns on a 25 man roster. Damaso Marte also came up through the Yankee system and Matsui hasn’t played for any other MLB club. So, please check your facts…I wonder howmany “homegrowns” Philly has? I bet its no where near as many as the Yanks.

user-pic

I second the David Justice remark. He was an Atlanta Brave homegrown talent. Braun you are an idiot and a horrible fact checker. Does the Badger Herald even have an editor?

user-pic

David Justice - a homegrown Yankee? Just like Cliff Lee & Raul Ibanez are homegrown Phillies, right?

This is the second article I’ve read by Mr. Braun (the other being an aimless diatribe about a police officer who, btw, works a lot harder than Mr. Braun realizes) with incorrect (and probably made up) facts.

Paging Mr. Editor…where are you?

user-pic

blegh. non-students with agendas should be prohibited from posting on here.

user-pic

That David Justice error is an unfortunate one, since he was drafted by the Braves and won a championship with them, en route to being inducted into their Hall of Fame in 2007. And it comes on this, the 14th anniversary of his series-winning homerun in game 6 of the 1995 World Series.

Jorge Posade and Mariano Rivera coudl have been easily substituted.

user-pic

Jonah Braun can do no wrong.

Leave a comment

To comment anonymously or if signed in, leave name and e-mail blank.

Donate